This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy for details.
This isn’t simply tastier than store-bought jars—it’s extra reasonably priced too! You can also make it together with your favourite cookies, whether or not it’s crunchy gingersnaps, luscious vanilla wafers, or the normal speculoos. This recipe is versatile sufficient to allow you to customise the consistency and texture to your liking, whether or not you like it clean or chunky. Plus, it’s good for spreading on toast, drizzling over pancakes, or consuming straight from the spoon.
Why Our Recipe
- Extra scrumptious and cheaper than store-bought jars.
- Versatile on which cookies you utilize so you possibly can play with your individual favorites.
- Did we point out how scrumptious cookie butter is?
The craze for cookie butter! It’s widespread and never one thing that’s all the time obtainable at each grocery retailer so why not make it from dwelling? My children adore it and it’s one thing that they get of their stocking at Christmas time, however for people who don’t reside the place there’s a Dealer Joe’s, this selfmade recipe would be the subsequent smartest thing.
Ingredient Notes
- Cookies: Biscoff (speculoos) cookies are the normal alternative, however they are often exhausting to search out relying on the place you reside. Gingersnaps are an excellent substitute, and ‘Nilla wafers would make for a superb clean vanilla taste.
- Salted Butter: Helps bind the components collectively and enriches the unfold’s creamy texture, including a refined savory stability to the sweetness.
- Scorching Water: Use additional to regulate the consistency of your cookie butter if you might want to skinny it out.
- Honey: Might be substituted with sweetened condensed milk, maple syrup, and even molasses if you need these wealthy darkish undertones.
Cookie Butter Makes use of
- Breakfast Aptitude: unfold on toast, bagels, or English muffins. It’s additionally improbable drizzled over waffles or pancakes.
- Dip It: seize some recent apple slices, pretzels, and even cookies, and dip them proper into the jar. That’s proper, cookies on cookies. It’s acceptable.
- Drizzle It: use it as an ice cream topping, swirl it into yogurt, or use it as a filling for crepes.
- Bake with It: use it as a filling for pastries and cinnamon rolls. Are you able to even think about how scrumptious cookie butter cinnamon rolls are?
- Dessert Sandwiches: unfold on sandwiches with recent fruit or jam. Bananas and berries are scrumptious. Or make a fluffernutter-style sandwich with marshmallow fluff and cookie butter. Oh, child!
Chunky or Clean?
Similar to peanut butter, some prefer it clean, some prefer it chunky. It’s all about the way you mix it.
For a clean texture, mix till the cookies grow to be very wonderful crumbs, including a bit extra sizzling water if wanted to attain a creamy consistency.
For a chunky texture, pulse the cookies to a rough crumb. You may even stir in some reserved cookie items after mixing the opposite components to make it additional chunky.
Storage Directions
Retailer at room temperature in an hermetic container for as much as 7 days; the pantry is ok for short-term storage.
Refrigerate in an hermetic container for as much as 1 month. Observe that the cookie butter will harden and never be as spreadable so deliver it to room temperature earlier than utilizing or unfold it on one thing sizzling.
